Below is everything you wanted to know and more on how Handicap Strokes should be allocated for your next competitive round of golf.
What is a Handicap Stroke?
It is a stroke applied to a gross score which, in effect, subtracts the player’s handicap stroke(s) from the player’s gross score for a hole or round, which is referred to the player’s net score.
What is the purpose of allocating handicap strokes to certain holes?
Basically, it is to equalize the abilities of players at different handicap levels. It allows a 30- handicap player to equitably compete against a 15-handicap player. Some formats apply stroke holes or ‘pops’ on a hole-by-hole basis, for instance in Four-Ball stroke play and Skins, whereas in an 18-hole Net Competition, the total Course Handicap is used to determine the net score.
Who determines the allocation of handicap strokes?
Either the club’s Handicap Committee or a Committee formed to allocate handicap-stroke holes by collecting hole-by-hole data as recommended by the USGA in Section 17 of the USGA Handicap System Manual. The SCGA provides the rating and slope for each set of tees which is not related to the stroke hole allocation. However, the SCGA offers a service where if the club provides a spreadsheet with the necessary number of hole-by-hole scores, with Course Handicaps for each score provided, the SCGA will provide both forms of analysis identified by the USGA.
Should men and women have different stroke hole allocations? Should each set of tees have a different stroke hole allocation?
Stroke hole allocations for men and women should be different because the need to equalize holes will be different for men than for women. However, a single allocation for men and one separate one for women is the most practical and easiest for players to utilize even when there are multiple sets of tees.
In a mixed Four-Ball competition (women and men play their own ball and record the best score), which stroke hole allocation should be used for the competition?
Women would use their stroke hole allocation and men would use their stroke hole allocation in all formats where players play their own ball.
How often should stroke hole allocations be reviewed or updated?
There are no set rules, however the USGA recommends that a committee should review scorecards and determine scoring averages every five years or after major renovations have been made to the course.
How many scorecards need to be collected?
About 500 scorecards from play from the most commonly used set of tees. Group A should represent players with a Course Handicap of 8 or below for men and 14 or below for women.
If a club does not have enough low handicap players, the committee can use scorecards from 25% of its players with the lowest course handicap (however, these scorecards should not be adjusted by Equitable Stroke Control.)
Group B should represent hole-by-hole scores for middle to higher handicap players. Men should fall between course handicaps of 20-28 and women, 26-40. In general, the average of the Course Handicap of players in Group B should be 15-20 strokes higher than the average Course Handicap of the players in Group A.
Why are odd numbered stroke holes always on the front nine and even numbered stroke holes on the back nine?
Unless the back nine of a golf course is determined to be more difficult than the front nine, the odd/even distribution best equalizes the distribution of handicap strokes over the entire 18-holes.
Where should the #1 stroke hole be allocated?
The first allocated stroke hole does not mean it is the hardest hole on the course but it should be the hole where the stroke is most useful in a match between players of almost equal ability, for instance between a 10 and an 11 or a 29 or a 31-course handicap. In the USGA’s article, the “Great Equalizer”, answer this question, if you were to receive only one handicap stroke against an opponent, which hole would you want to receive that stroke? Picture your home course and pick the hole where you would want that one stroke. See, usga.org/content/usga/home-page/handicapping/handicapping-101/the-great-equalizer-25498.html
No. Although the comparison method of allocating stroke holes is probably the method used by most clubs, the more inclusive method outlined in Section 17 of the USGA Handicap System Manual is the Regression Method wherein a minimum of 400 hole-by-hole scorecards are used (regardless of player’s course handicaps) to determine the distribution of stroke holes which includes hole-by-hole scores from all players, including a club's "average" players (golfers with Course Handicap values in the teens) and not just low and higher handicap players.
To view a sameple scorecard for match play between two players with different handicaps, click here.